Stabbed Social Worker won the right to sue for breach of Duty of Care

March 3, 2016

A social worker who was stabbed by a mental patient who had earlier threatened to ‘kill her on the spot’ won the right to sue two NHS trusts after the Court of Appeal ruled it was arguable that they owed her a common law duty of care. 

The patient had issued the threat two days before the near-fatal attack on Claire Selwood when she was stabbed in 2006 but she was not informed of what he had said. 

Ms Selwood sought compensation from her employers at the time, Durham County Council, and two NHS trusts which were involved in treating the mental patient prior to the attack.  

Worker Stabbed: Negligence through Failure to Share Information

After a preliminary hearing, a judge struck out Ms Selwood’s claim against the trusts, ruling that it would not be ‘fair, just and reasonable’ to impose a common law duty of care upon them in the circumstances. 

However, overturning that ruling at the Court of Appeal, Dame Janet Smith said Ms Selwood was one of a small group of social workers, operating as part of a multi-disciplinary team in close proximity and co-operation with the trusts’ staff.   

The judge, sitting with Lords Justice Thorpe and Rimer, said Ms Selwood was ‘in a special position’ and it would be open to the judge who will now hear her damages claim against all three defendants to find that the trusts owed her a duty of care. 

  Ms Selwood’s lawyers argue that, had she been warned of the threat made by the mental patient, she would have taken steps to protect herself. 

  However, the trusts submit that, as the mental patient was not compulsorily detained and Ms Selwood was not employed by them, they cannot be held legally responsible for the attack. They also argue that it was not reasonably foreseeable that Ms Selwood was under an immediate threat of violence. 

  The Court of Appeal’s ruling means that Ms Selwood’s case against the Tees, Esk and Wear Valleys NHS Foundation Trust, the Northumberland, Tyne and Wear NHS Foundation Trust and Durham County Council will now go ahead to a full hearing on all issues. 

Dynamis provides very popular and successful courses in  Lone Worker Personal Safety  which aim to prepare the individual for the various avoidance, defusing and personal protection measures they may need to stay safe as a worker alone in the community.   

Story Courtesy of WBW Solicitors

Care and Control 4

Gerard O’Dea is a conflict management, personal safety and physical interventions training consultant.  He is the training director for Dynamis, a specialist in personal safety and violence reduction initiatives and the European Adviser for ‘Verbal Defense and Influence’, a global programme which addresses the spectrum of human conflict.

Gerard’s book on Lone Worker Personal Safety is available on Amazon Kindle and Paperback.

National Personal Safety Day - Lone Working Book from Dynamis

Related Posts

How to NOT end up on Panorama – decision making as culture.

How to NOT end up on Panorama – decision making as culture.

How many people should we train in positive handling in our school?

How many people should we train in positive handling in our school?

Our Trainer programme for a Children’s Hospital

Our Trainer programme for a Children’s Hospital

Introduction to SCENA

Introduction to SCENA


Gerard O'Dea is the Director of Training for Dynamis. Training Advisor, Speaker, Author and Expert Witness on Personal Safety, Conflict Management and Physical Interventions, he is the European Advisor for Vistelar Conflict Management, a global programme focussing on the spectrum of human conflict.

Gerard O'Dea

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}